New York City's Best Ooey
Gooey Cookies

oprah's favorite things 2024

Visit Us!

Phone: (646) 972-0409

163 Chrystie Street Basement
New York, NY 10002

Monday - Thursday: Closed

Friday: 2pm-1am

Saturday: 12pm-1am

Sunday: 12pm-10pm

 
 

Phone: (646)454-0942

119 Christopher Street
New York, NY 10014

Monday:  12pm-10pm

Tuesday:  12pm-10pm

Wednesday:  12pm-10pm

Thursday: 12pm-10pm

Friday:  12pm-12am

Saturday:  12pm-12am

Sunday:  12pm-10pm

Gooey On the Inside Cookies

Every great story begins with a dream, and mine started in a cozy Chelsea kitchen, where the humble oven became my sanctuary. As a self-proclaimed emotional eater, I’ve always had a special connection with food—it's more than just sustenance; it’s a passion fueled by the flavors of my Caribbean roots and the chill of Canadian winters. The mission was simple yet ambitious: to create a cookie that would capture both the crispy edge and the gooey center—a perfect balance of textures that would take you on a flavor adventure with every bite. 

After countless trials, missteps, and bursts of inspiration, I finally unveiled my creation, the “Gooey on the Inside” cookie. Each cookie tells a story of persistence, of moments spent perfecting the recipe, and of the joy that comes from sharing something delicious with others. Join me on this journey as we celebrate the love of cookies and the memories they help create. There’s magic in the kitchen, and I can’t wait to share more of it with you!

Your favorite childhood breakfast, reimagined! Buttery, fruity, and irresistibly gooey, this cookie brings all the nostalgic goodness of jam on toast with a decadent twist.

Viral Jam on Toast

Brownie Biscoff

Rich, fudgy brownie meets caramelized Biscoff goodness in one outrageously gooey cookie. A chocolate lover's dream!

Sweet caramelized apples, creamy Brie, and a touch of honey come together in this irresistible sweet-and-savory cookie. Unexpectedly delicious!

Caramelized Apple & Brie

Gooey On the Inside Cookies

S’mores

A sumptuous blend of French milk chocolate, dark chocolate, marshmallows and dark chocolate cookie make this childhood treat come to life. Ooey-Gooey perfection in every bite.

A blend of sweet white chocolate, tart raspberry, toasted almonds, and a subtle hint of rose for a soft, gooey bite.

Almond Raspberry Rose

Creamy cheesecake, juicy peach, and swirls of Biscoff come together in this soft, gooey cookie, finished with a buttery Biscoff crumble for the perfect sweet crunch.

Peach Biscoff Cheesecake

Molten Cookie in a Jar

8oz/$15
16oz/$23
This warm molten cookie in a jar is not just a treat; it’s a hug in dessert form!

With every bite you’ll get warm gooey blackberry jam on toast cookie dough layered with white chocolate ganache.

Blackberry Jam on Toast

With every bite you’ll get warm gooey apple pie cookie dough layered with white chocolate ganache.

Almond Raspberry Rose

Peach Biscoff Cheesecake

With every bite you’ll get warm gooey peach biscoff cheesecake cookie dough layered with white chocolate ganache.

Birthday
Cake

With every bite you’ll get warm gooey birthday cake cookie dough layered with white chocolate ganache.

Chocolate Chip Chunk

With every bite you’ll get warm gooey chocolate chip chunk cookie dough layered with chocolate ganache.

S’Mores

With every bite you’ll get warm gooey s’mores cookie dough layered with chocolate ganache and marshmallow fluff.

The Bueno Bueno

With every bite you’ll get warm gooey bueno bueno cookie dough layered with chocolate ganache.

12 oz / $19.99

What Is Gooey Cookie Spread?

Your favorite Gooey cookies transformed into rich, creamy, irresistible spreads! Perfect for toast, pancakes, ice cream, dipping, or straight from the spoon.

Gooey Cookie Spreads

All the buttery, chocolatey goodness of our signature Chocolate Chip Chunk Cookie in a deliciously creamy spread.

Chocolate Chip Chunk

Sweet vanilla cake flavor and buttery cookie goodness in a creamy, celebration-worthy spread!

Birthday Cake

Viral Jam on Toast

Buttery cookie goodness meets sweet, raspberry jam flavors in this nostalgic, spoon-worthy creation.

Brownie Biscoff

Rich, fudgy chocolate brownie meets caramelized Biscoff in a decadent, velvety spread.

Dark Chocolate Caramel S'mores

Rich dark chocolate, luscious caramel, and toasted marshmallow flavors come together in one indulgent spread.

Warm Scoopable Cookie dough

Solo Scoop (serves 1): $15, Family Scoop (serves 4): $34.99

Our classic scoopable dough loaded with rich chocolate chunks and that signature gooey goodness in every bite.


Chocolate Chip Chunk

Sweet vanilla cake batter dough packed with colorful sprinkles and white chocolate for a nostalgic birthday treat. 

Birthday Cake

Rich, fudgy brownie meets caramelized Biscoff goodness in one outrageously gooey cookie. A chocolate lover's dream!

Brownie Biscoff

Deep dark chocolate dough swirled with gooey caramel, toasted marshmallow, and graham cracker pieces. 

Dark Chocolate Caramel S’mores

Creamy cheesecake dough blended with juicy peach and spiced Biscoff cookie crumble for a rich, fruity finish. 

Peach Biscoff Cheesecake

Buttery cinnamon toast-inspired dough layered with sweet blackberry jam for the perfect cozy-meets-fruity bite. 

Viral Jam on Toast

Cookie Bites

6 pcs/$14
Bite sized versions of our ooey gooey cookies!