New York City's Best Ooey
Gooey Cookies
oprah's favorite things 2024
MENU
🍪
MENU 🍪
Cookies
6oz/$8.15 each
Birthday Cake
Now it can be your birthday everyday! This birthday cake cookie comes complete imported French white chocolate chunks, real birthday cake flavor, colorful sprinkles and an ooey gooey center. You'll enjoy every last bite.
The Bueno Bueno
Hazelnut cream filling, milk and white chocolate and Kinder Bueno pieces.
Chocolate Chip Chunk
Our chocolate chip cookies are Melt-in-Your-Mouth! Rich dark and milk chocolate chips are combined with dark chocolate chunks in a delicious golden cookie.
Biscoff & Cream
A golden brown cookie filled with luscious biscoff and white chocolate chunks.
Red Velvet
A cookie that perfectly marries the richness of chocolate with the eye-catching allure of a vibrant red hue and the tang of a cream cheese frosting filling.
Apple Pie
Filled with apple pie filling and topped with sweet, buttery crumble.
S’mores
A sumptuous blend of French milk chocolate, dark chocolate, marshmallows and dark chocolate cookie make this childhood treat come to life. Ooey-Gooey perfection in every bite.
Banana Cream Pie
Each bite is a journey through layers of real banana goodness, sweet white chocolate, and a surprise burst of banana jam.
Fan Favorite 6-pack
$49
We've brought back our 6 best selling cookies for a limited time! Indulge in the classic chocolate chip chunk, celebration-worthy Birthday Cake, luscious Red Velvet, dreamy Biscoff, delightful Banana Cream Pie and comforting Apple Pie......And did we mention it's one of Oprah's favorite things for 2024!
Molten Cookie in a Jar
8oz/$15
16oz/$23
This warm molten cookie in a jar is not just a treat; it’s a hug in dessert form!
Apple Pie
With every bite you’ll get warm gooey apple pie cookie dough layered with white chocolate ganache.
Banana Cream Pie
With every bite you’ll get warm gooey banana cream pie cookie dough layered with white chocolate ganache.
Red Velvet
With every bite you’ll get warm gooey red velvet cookie dough layered with white chocolate ganache.
Birthday Cake
With every bite you’ll get warm gooey birthday cake cookie dough layered with white chocolate ganache.
Biscoff & Cream
With every bite you’ll get warm gooey biscoff & cream cookie dough layered with white chocolate ganache.
Chocolate Chip Chunk
With every bite you’ll get warm gooey chocolate chip chunk cookie dough layered with chocolate ganache.
S’Mores
With every bite you’ll get warm gooey s’mores cookie dough layered with chocolate ganache and marshmallow fluff.
The Bueno Bueno
With every bite you’ll get warm gooey bueno bueno cookie dough layered with chocolate ganache.
Croissandwich
$15/each
Chocolate Chip Chunk
Warm Chocolate chip chunk cookie dough, chocolate ganache and vanilla ice cream sandwiched between a warm, flaky croissant
Birthday Cake
Warm birthday cake cookie dough, white chocolate ganache and vanilla ice cream sandwiched between a warm, flaky croissant
Apple Pie
Warm apple pie cookie dough, apple pie filling and vanilla ice cream sandwiched between a warm, flaky croissant
S’mores
Warm S’mores cookie dough, chocolate ganache, caramel, marshmallow fluff and vanilla ice cream sandwiched between a warm, flaky croissant
Biscoff & Cream
Warm Chocolate chip chunk cookie dough, biscoff spread, biscoff crumbs and vanilla ice cream sandwiched between a warm, flaky croissant
The Bueno Bueno
Warm bueno cookie dough, nutella, custard and vanilla ice cream sandwiched between a warm, flaky croissant
Cookie Bites
6 pcs/$14
Bite sized versions of our ooey gooey cookies!
Every great story begins with a dream, and mine started in a cozy Chelsea kitchen, where the humble oven became my sanctuary. As a self-proclaimed emotional eater, I’ve always had a special connection with food—it's more than just sustenance; it’s a passion fueled by the flavors of my Caribbean roots and the chill of Canadian winters. The mission was simple yet ambitious: to create a cookie that would capture both the crispy edge and the gooey center—a perfect balance of textures that would take you on a flavor adventure with every bite.
After countless trials, missteps, and bursts of inspiration, I finally unveiled my creation, the “Gooey on the Inside” cookie. Each cookie tells a story of persistence, of moments spent perfecting the recipe, and of the joy that comes from sharing something delicious with others. Join me on this journey as we celebrate the love of cookies and the memories they help create. There’s magic in the kitchen, and I can’t wait to share more of it with you!
Come find us in person!
M, W, Th: 4pm-10pm
F: 4pm-1am
Sat: 12pm-1am
SUN: 12PM-10PM
Phone: (646) 972-0409
Address: 163 Chrystie Street Basement
New York, NY 10002